The Pendleton Rail Trail, a beloved off-roading destination in Niagara County, is facing a significant change. The Town of Pendleton’s decision to close the ATV section of the trail has stirred up a mix of emotions and opinions among local residents and off-road enthusiasts.

The trail, which stretches from Townline Road to Lockport Road, has long been a popular spot for both bikers and ATV riders. However, the town board’s recent vote to shut down the off-roading side has left many wondering about the future of ATV recreation in the area.

The Decision and Its Implications

Pendleton Supervisor Joel Maerten explained that the closure will take effect once the new law is approved by New York State and appropriate signage is posted. The Niagara County Sheriff’s Office will oversee enforcement, with violators facing fines and vehicle towing.

Maerten emphasized the town’s reluctance to make this decision, stating, “A lot of people enjoy it; we don’t want to say no. We just want to see it happen safely, and at the moment, we don’t have any other options but to turn it off.” The primary concern cited is the liability associated with operating an ATV trail, a responsibility few municipalities are willing to undertake.

Community Reactions

Not everyone is on board with the town’s decision. Mike Forestera resident who lives near the trail, questioned the liability argument. “If you’re going to keep the trail [open for runners/bikers], somebody could go off the edge of the trail on a bicycle and break a leg,” he pointed out, challenging the town’s rationale.

Forester’s concerns echo those of Bob Weaverowner of Bob Weaver Motorsports. Weaver expressed worries that closing the trails could drive riders to more dangerous areas. “If they’re not going to be riding on trails, they are going to be riding on the streets. Riding on the road is the most dangerous thing, especially on a dirt bike or any vehicle not made for road use.” He stressed the importance of designated off-road areas, stating, “That’s what it was designed and built for.

Looking Ahead

Despite the closure, Maerten remains open to finding a solution that could reopen the trail. “I’m open to some ideas,” he said, but emphasized the need for community collaboration. “If people want to see it come back, we need to see some real commitment to collaborating with the town.

For now, the future of ATV riding on the Pendleton Rail Trail remains uncertain. As the community grapples with this change, the hope is that a compromise can be found that satisfies both the town’s concerns and the desires of off-road enthusiasts.